you're reading...

Cheaper eyesight saving drug should be more widely used


Watching Dame Judi Dench in her latest film, you would never guess that she is suffering from a serious eye condition and risks going blind.

Dench recently went public over the fact she has age-related macular degeneration and can no longer read scripts or see faces clearly – a brave move for an actor whose livelihood could be threatened.

She is receiving treatment to stop her eyesight getting worse.

But there is a story to tell behind the treatment she’s receiving, one that involves patient safety, scarce NHS resources, the drug industry and the regulators.

Dench has wet age-related macular degeneration (AMD), which is the leading cause of blindness in the Western world.

What is wet AMD

Image on left is a healthy retina. Image on right is a scarred retina from wet AMD

Image on left is a healthy retina. Image on right is a scarred retina from wet AMD

Blood vessels at the back of the eye leak proteins on the macula, the crucial part of the retina, that captures the images we see. People lose their central vision and the ability to see clearly. In some advanced cases people go blind. Here is leading ophthalmologist Professor Harminder Singh Dua explaining the condition:


There are two drugs available for this condition: Lucentis, which costs £740 injection, and Avastin, which costs a mere £20 per treatment.

So surely everyone is treated with the cheaper drug, Avastin.

But this is not the case because of the regulatory system in the UK.

Avastin has not been through the official regulatory process of drug licensing with the Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Health Agency for use in AMD.

There have been a number of clinical trials comparing the two drugs and systematic reviews of the evidence. To date both drugs have been found to be equally as effective and safe.

Impact the drug costs of Lucentis on the NHS

Eye specialists are increasingly frustrated and angry because they are seeing their drug budgets eaten up by the costs of treating the 200,000 people with wet AMD.  And this is at a time when the NHS needs to find find efficiency savings of £20bn.

Mr Michel Michaelides a consultant ophthalmologist said the issue of whether to use Avastin or Lucentis “is the single most important issue in ophthalmology…. and is particularly pertinent due to the financial crisis the NHS is in.”

Ophthalmologists are now witnessing other eyesight saving services, such as cataract surgery being rationed.

Professor Dua, president of the Royal College of Ophthalmologists

Professor Dua says this has got to stop and has called on the Government to give guidance to doctors about when they can use Avastin.

The problem is that Lucentis is licensed for use on eyes but Avastin is not. But a twist in the tale is that Avastin is a licensed drug but only for use in colon cancer.

A further twist is that doctors are not supposed to use an unlicensed medicine if there is a licensed one available.

In the private sector things are different. There is widespread use of the cheaper drug Avastin for AMD because people pay for their treatment so costs matter.

It is also the favoured treatment in the United States on cost grounds.

In some areas of the UK, NHS managers are understandably asking their clinicians to use the cheaper drug. Southampton Primary Care Trust, the body responsible for commissioning eye services is one example.

Dr Bob Coates, a public health consultant for Southampton PCT said, “There’s a finite allocation and we need to get as much as we can out of health budgets. If we can achieve an equivalent outcome for a fraction of the cost why wouldn’t you? That way we can re-invest and buy more health care.”

But this action has upset the drug company who manufactures the more expensive drug, Lucentis.

Novartis said in a statement: “If the NHS encourages the use of unlicensed medicines, without regard to the availability of appropriately licensed alternatives, this will represent a disincentive to the research and development of innovative new medicines, particularly in ophthalmology… it undermines the regulatory process that was introduced to safeguard patients.”

However, the reality for the NHS, where budgets are being squeezed, is that money needs to go as far as possible.

Department of Health guidance

The Department of Health has issued the following guidance: “In the absence of National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence guidance… it is for local PCTs to decide whether to fund treatment… there is nothing to stop clinicians from prescribing Avastin for the treatment of AMD if they think it is the most clinically appropriate and available treatment.”

But some  doctors and other interested parties don’t necessarily want to see the slippery slide into the widespread use of unlicensed medicines

The whole thing is a mess, and an expensive one at that.

So far there’s an impasse.

On one side there are doctors and patients saying Avastin should be a special case.

On the other side are the regulators, the drug industry and some doctors and campaigners who fear the long term consequences of such an exception being made.

Given the importance of the pharmaceutical industry to the UK’s economy is seems unlikely that the Government will want to frighten off potential future investment.

The arguments on both sides are legitimate and have clear merits.

Given the NHS has finite resources, this issue is going to test the new commissioning landscape.

Will commissioners have the guts to make decisions in the interests of their local population when there are such powerful national economic and political vested interests at stake?

Health retina image courtesy of Richard Masoner.

Picture of Judi Dench courtesy of Wikimedia Commons http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Judi_Dench_at_the_BAFTAs_2007.jpg


No comments yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: